New City, NY Investment Properties

9,500 results

Find, analyze, and compare New City, NY investment properties, including off-market opportunities and residential homes with value-add potential. New City offers a diverse housing market with single-family homes, and vacant properties. Investors can explore potential investment opportunities for long-term rentals (LTRs) throughout New York. Explore housing market trends in New City, where up-and-coming neighborhoods may offer potential for passive rental income and other investment strategies. Property Intel by Whitepages makes it easy to analyze market trends, uncover off-market properties, compare neighborhood benchmarks, and access owner contact information to help you find the best investment properties in New City, NY for your real estate goals.

In New City, the median property value currently stands at $530,014, reflecting a 0.75% year-over-year increase based on recent sales. The 5-year appreciation forecast estimates values reaching $819,778 (a 0.01% gain). The housing market includes a total of 10,484 houses.The median home in New City has 2,250 square feet of living space, priced at a median of $238 per square foot with a median year built of 1969. For long-term rental properties in New City, the median annual gross rental income is $42,000 (or $3,500/month) with estimated operating expenses of $26,174, resulting in an approximate gross cap rate of 2.78%.

Property Intel by Whitepages helps investors and homeowners explore the New City area by offering market analysis tools, neighborhood benchmarks, owner contact information, and interactive maps. These tools support research into investment properties, including foreclosure data and off-market listings in New City, NY.

$685K - $741K
Est. Value
12 Radcliff Dr
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 3.5 baths • 1,960 sq ft
19,166 sq ft lot • Built: 1959
Last Sold: $397K in 2003
$310K - $333K
Est. Value
22 Heritage Dr Apt F
New City, NY 10956
10956
2 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,270 sq ft
2,178 sq ft lot • Built: 1972
Last Sold: $192K in 2001
$588K - $636K
Est. Value
2 Dore Ct
New City, NY 10956
5 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,652 sq ft
38,333 sq ft lot • Built: 1970
Last Sold: $530K in 2009
$687K - $810K
Est. Value
6 Kings Hwy
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 3 baths • 3,938 sq ft
27,878 sq ft lot • Built: 2008
Last Sold: $748K in 2014
$540K - $643K
Est. Value
129 Third St
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 2 baths • 1,920 sq ft
16,988 sq ft lot • Built: 1972
Last Sold: $110K in 1984
$712K - $779K
Est. Value
41 Lombardi Dr
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 3 baths • 2,838 sq ft
20,038 sq ft lot • Built: 1961
Last Sold: $123K in 1982
$579K - $623K
Est. Value
6 Peachtree Ter
New City, NY 10956
10970
4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,764 sq ft
25,265 sq ft lot • Built: 1957
Last Sold: $249K in 1999
$610K - $678K
Est. Value
10 Round Pond Ct
New City, NY 10956
10970
3 beds • 3 baths • 2,373 sq ft
40,511 sq ft lot • Built: 1994
Last Sold: $395K in 2015
$546K - $697K
Est. Value
8 Fayva Ct
New City, NY 10956
5 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,258 sq ft
14,810 sq ft lot • Built: 1998
Last Sold: $359K in 2015
$339K - $361K
Est. Value
12 Heritage Dr Apt B
New City, NY 10956
10956
2 beds • 2 baths • 1,185 sq ft
2,178 sq ft lot • Built: 1971
Last Sold: $220K in 2016
$465K - $531K
Est. Value
3 Woodbine Rd
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 1 bath • 1,608 sq ft
22,216 sq ft lot • Built: 1953
Last Sold: $360K in 2004
$406K - $435K
Est. Value
12 Braemar Ct
New City, NY 10956
10956
2 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,423 sq ft
5,227 sq ft lot • Built: 1985
Last Sold: $427K in 2006
$642K - $762K
Est. Value
6 Conklin Rd
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 2.5 baths • 3,720 sq ft
87,120 sq ft lot • Built: 2007
Last Sold: $500K in 2018
$337K - $361K
Est. Value
31 Heritage Dr Apt B
New City, NY 10956
10956
2 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,270 sq ft
2,178 sq ft lot • Built: 1972
Last Sold: $342K in 2021
$447K - $515K
Est. Value
17 Elinor Pl
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,384 sq ft
12,632 sq ft lot • Built: 1983
Last Sold: $120K in 1983
$463K - $531K
Est. Value
25 Hoover Ln
New City, NY 10956
10956
4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,215 sq ft
21,344 sq ft lot • Built: 1978
Last Sold: $66.5K in 1978
$419K - $459K
Est. Value
5 Mark Ln
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,868 sq ft
29,185 sq ft lot • Built: 1958
Last Sold: $425K in 2004
$602K - $687K
Est. Value
81 Red Hill Rd
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 3 baths • 2,630 sq ft
26,572 sq ft lot • Built: 1998
Last Sold: $300K in 1998
$672K - $738K
Est. Value
16 Manor Ct
New City, NY 10956
5 beds • 4.5 baths • 4,471 sq ft
100,188 sq ft lot • Built: 1979
Last Sold: $965K in 2013
$545K - $628K
Est. Value
43 Eberling Dr
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 3.5 baths • 2,546 sq ft
17,424 sq ft lot • Built: 1993
Last Sold: $615K in 2023
$464K - $506K
Est. Value
10 Hansen Ave
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 3 baths • 2,201 sq ft
11,326 sq ft lot • Built: 1947
Last Sold: $477K in 2019
$817K - $886K
Est. Value
2 Doolin Rd
New City, NY 10956
10956
5 beds • 2.5 baths • 3,500 sq ft
34,848 sq ft lot • Built: 1999
Last Sold: $658K in 2004
$464K - $513K
Est. Value
33 Lindbergh Ln
New City, NY 10956
5 beds • 3 baths • 2,255 sq ft
10,454 sq ft lot • Built: 2002
Last Sold: $490K in 2003
$493K - $531K
Est. Value
385 New Hempstead Rd
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,106 sq ft
27,007 sq ft lot • Built: 1998
Last Sold: $164K in 1998
$526K - $600K
Est. Value
51 Leona Ave
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 2 baths • 1,900 sq ft
14,810 sq ft lot • Built: 1955
Last Sold: $620K in 2021
$607K - $683K
Est. Value
79 Red Hill Rd
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 3 baths • 3,067 sq ft
22,216 sq ft lot • Built: 1997
Last Sold: $575K in 2019
$342K - $361K
Est. Value
28 Heritage Dr Apt D
New City, NY 10956
10956
2 beds • 2.5 baths • 1,200 sq ft
2,178 sq ft lot • Built: 1974
Last Sold: $329K in 2020
$614K - $692K
Est. Value
6 Boecher Ct
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 3 baths • 2,621 sq ft
25,700 sq ft lot • Built: 1960
Last Sold: $216K in 1986
$534K - $573K
Est. Value
13 Bradley Dr
New City, NY 10956
3 beds • 2 baths • 1,896 sq ft
17,860 sq ft lot • Built: 1959
Last Sold: $458K in 2014
$603K - $655K
Est. Value
16 Prince St
New City, NY 10956
4 beds • 2.5 baths • 2,859 sq ft
17,860 sq ft lot • Built: 1972
Last Sold: $536K in 2009

PreviousPageof 13

NYNew City

Housing Market Trends & Statistics for New City, New York

Median Property Value

$530,014

Total number of Properties

10,484

Median Living Space

2,250 sq ft

Median Year Built

1969 (56 years)

5-Year Appreciation Forecast

$819,778

Median Lot Size

20,038 sq ft

Average Ownership

1 year 4 months

for New City, NY

Est. Rental Income
$42,000 ($3,500 per month)
Net Operating Income
$15,826 ($1,319 per month)
Cap Rate
2.78%

New City, NY Investment Properties

Housing Market Trends & Statistics for New City, New York

rental income

Find Investment Properties in New City

Nearby Cities

Nearby Neighborhoods

Nearby ZIP Codes

Nearby Counties

New City, NY Investment Properties

Housing Market Trends & Statistics for New City, New York

rental income

Find Investment Properties in New City

Nearby Cities

Nearby Neighborhoods

Nearby ZIP Codes

Nearby Counties

Frequently Asked Questions

How has the housing market in New City, NY performed recently?

What is the median home value and average price per square foot in New City, NY?

How does New City perform for long-term rental investments?

How can I find off-market properties in New City?

How can I find foreclosures or distressed properties in New City?